Algorithmic Segregation

Is YouTube racist?

Yesterday, I went to YouTube to listen to William Grant Still’s ‘Afro-American Symphony’, to my delight, the recommendations that appeared to the side featured the music of diverse composers, such as Florence Price, the first African-American woman to have her compositions played by a major symphony orchestra, and Joseph Boulogne, who many (problematically) dub the ‘Black Mozart’. 

After my initial delight subsided, it dawned on me that in order to find female and POC composers, I had to actively search for them. I encourage you to try this experiment for yourself: go onto YouTube and search any white composer, for example, I searched Aaron Copland, and naturally his famous ‘Appalachian Spring’ was the first result. The recommended videos that accompany this are all music by white composers: Gershwin, Wagner, Rachmaninov, Stravinsky, Ravel, Vaughan Williams, and Prokofiev. Now, these are all incredible composers (some with more troubling views than others) but their music is so varied and within it there can be found plenty of musical diversity. 

So, why can’t the likes of William Grant Still or Florence Price be found as a related video? To what extent is this the fault of the Western Canon consisting of, almost exclusively, white men? To what extent is it our own fault for buying into this idea of accepting a ‘white-washed’ version of history? The YouTube algorithm remains a mystery but could they do more to recommend these diverse composers when people are exploring classical music on their platform? Probably. I don’t code but if they manage to promote late night talk show hosts to everyone and their dog, as though they lay slap-bang in the centre of the Venn diagram of human interest, I’m sure they could do more to ensure there isn’t seemingly an algorithmic segregation on their platform. 

Racism within the music industry isn’t new and YouTube is such a predominant streaming service that I believe they owe it to these musicians to promote their work and have their beautiful music heard by new generations. Classical music can often seem elitist and inaccessible to women and POC but it is my hope that more diverse voices will be given the chance to influence and shape the industry in the years to come.

Header Image Credit: Sparx Logo

Author

Phoebe Haroon

Phoebe Haroon

2nd year music student and new mum; I love learning and teaching.

We need your help supporting young creatives

Recent posts by this author

View more posts by Phoebe Haroon

1 Comments

  • Hector Macduff

    On 19 February 2021, 12:29 Hector Macduff Kickstart Team commented:

    Yes! This is the problem with the algorithm of a few social media sites where they're designed to keep you there for as long as possible and show more white faces because more white people use it. Simultaneously justifying showing more white faces because people are "more likely to click on them" the discussion just becomes circular. In 2021 we need social media to up their game, great article Phoebe.

Post A Comment

You must be signed in to post a comment. Click here to sign in now

You might also like

Velociraptor: Krooked Tongue’s new single

Velociraptor: Krooked Tongue’s new single

by Candelaria Gómez

Read now